"Best Of"
 

I hope all songs from the soundtracks tracks that Lindsey has done are included on this compilation along with any unreleased gems. I would think a couple of new songs will be included.

At this stage of the game, I hope they flip things, and release the new studio album this year, and the Best Of in 2019!

I’d like to see him get out there ASAP. Totally agree on movie soundtracks as well! I’d like to see him ride the “wave” of support he’s got right now.

Yes I don’t care what he releases first. If he was planning to release Best Of and tour that then that’s what he should do ASAP! Not go back and wait. Not add extra songs. He can introduce any new songs live. He’s always waited and that’s exactly his problem. He should announce that best of this week. And upcoming tour week after that, even if he’s just setting up dates.

Folks he wasn't planning a Best Of album. Pretty sure Warners was planning it. They want to get a chunk of cash prior to him releasing his solo album. This is a large part of the reason the solo album has been pushed back, and in part why things got complicated with the tour.

Yes to all of this.

However- if he’s still under contract with that label, he needs to put it out. And he should do it as fast as possible!

Well, Lindsey's only under contract to Atlantic right now, so that shouldn't be an issue.
Plus, I would think Atlantic would want to cash in on the relative success of the Buckingham/McVie album, thus going with the new studio album.
If there is an issue, it might be deciding who's going to put it out....Elektra/Asylum or Warner/Reprise. They're both part of WEA, but they each have their own marketing and promotion budget. They all kind of have to be wondering how big this album will be, what with only two hit singles on it (three if he can get the rights to "Holiday Road").
I find the whole concept of a Best Of interesting...most labels won't put them out unless A) there's a lot to work with, material wise, B) it's a contractual obligation to maybe end a contract, C) WEA is thinking of deleting his entire catalog, thus consolidating it into one album, or D) the artist wants one out.

So, I'm not the absolute biggest of Lindsey Buckingham solo fans so I'm not in the best position to comment myself.
But...going on the premise of a 20 song disc. Would anyone volunteer a Best of Lindsey Buckingham track list suggestion???

This would not be my personal track list if I was compiling a Lindsey Best Of but I'd bet it will look an awful lot like this ---

Trouble
Holiday Road
Go Insane
Slow Dancing
Big Love (live, solo)
Wrong
Don’t Look Down
Countdown
Soul Drifter
Never Going Back Again (live, solo)
On The Wrong Side
Bleed To Love Her (live)
Show You How
Cast Away Dreams
Did You Miss Me
Seeds We Sow
In My World
Sleeping Around The Corner
Go Your Own Way (live)
New Song

for whatever reason i thought we already started this, but agree with you that the Best Of thread is probably the most appropriate place.

i expect it to be more like 12 than 20 songs. he's not commercial and record co doesn't wanna loose too much money.

some that i would love to see on Best Of - and hear LIVE!!!!! -

(i'm doing purely solo, no FM, other than bonus)

Down On Rodeo
Twist of Fate
Wait For You
Gift of Screws
Turn It On
In Our Own Time (but that's not on Reprise so idk whether it's eligible?)
Rock Away Blind (same as above)
That's the Way Love Goes (same as above)
Wrong
Holiday Road
Go Insane
Seeds We Sow (electric) (same as above)
You Do or You Don't
This is the Time
Johnny Stew
Underground
To Try for the Sun

bonus:
Red Rover
GYOW
Second Hand News

Live Tracks
 

I think Dreamisover has it correct, FM tracks can be included if they are live versions (but not live from an FM concert, only solo). I thought a live version of Stephanie might be included, but not now after the betrayal.

Stephanie should be eradicated--which is sad because it's a pretty song. I actually live Second Hand News better solo than with the Mac. Would hope he would include that!

His soundtracks songs must be included like Time Bomb Town.

Nineteen anythings, as long as it has DW suite in addition.

Maybe as the closer. A sweeter piece of music he's never crafted.

It's my one-song-on-a-deserted island piece. :nod:

I'd like to see a studio version of "My Little Demon" included!

Yes, please! No more Stephanie. Seriously, no more beating that old dead horse (figuratively and literally speaking) :lol:

I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Second Hand News live. And of course Fakewood Mac won't do it anymore, so I really hope it's on the setlist. :blob2:

Me too, I love that song!

Call me old-fashioned. I think it should be a Singles collection.

i hope not. his singles (that actually were released as singles) mostly suck. his Best Of however can be divine.

are we gonna argue about DYMM again??

or was that michele?

;)

lol maybe both of us? i can't stand Did you miss me. sounds so generic to me.

I'd assume Atlantic or any other label would only allow a Best of Album for LB to be at minimum 50% Mac songs.

If you are making a list you probably need to cap LB solo stuff to 8-10 songs, and likely you're just looking at the songs released as singles.

Probably something quite predictable like....


Go Your Own Way
Second Hand News
Never Going Back Again
Tusk
Oh Diane
Big Love
My Little Demon
Peacekeeper
Trouble
Go Insane
Wrong
Countdown
Show You How
Did You Miss Me
Love Runs Deeper
Seeds We Sow

Surely this will be a purely solo Lindsey Buckingham album. As people have said, Fleetwood Mac songs are only likely if they are live from Lindsey solo shows. Best of would most likely be his most notable solo songs (single releases) plus a selection of non-single releases. Not even sure it'd include Buckingham McVie songs either. We'll see.

nope. it's not Greatest Hits. it's Best Of. that (i hope!) will be very different.

i don't need LB's hits. i need his Best Of. and i need to hear those songs live.

We already have best of, and have heard multiple versions. The record companies already got us. They want to market to the biggest audience. I suspect you’ll be dissatisfied

another disappointment to add to this horrible year LB-wise.

we'll be lucky if he's allowed to put anything out. or tour. because remember band is painting him as reneging on tour promises - even though he didn't! he may be painted as too big of a risk or something.

[QUOTE=ryan4136;1226495]I'd assume Atlantic or any other label would only allow a Best of Album for LB to be at minimum 50% Mac songs.

If you are making a list you probably need to cap LB solo stuff to 8-10 songs, and likely you're just looking at the songs released as singles.

Probably something quite predictable like....


You are joking about their being mac songs on their right? NO CHANCE in hell.

I doubt there will be any Fleetwood Mac songs...much like Mick not allowing Stevie to include "Silver Springs" on "Timespace", I doubt Mick (and Warner Brothers) would agree to the release of any Mac tracks.

I'm also wondering if "Holiday Road" will be included? After all, that's up there with both "Trouble" and "Go Insane" as his most recognizable and commercially successful tracks.

What I'm expecting versus what I want;

Expecting
1) Trouble
2) It Was I
3) Holiday Road
4) Go Insane
5) Slow Dancing
6) Wrong
7) Countdown
8) Soul Drifter
9) Don't Look Down
10) Big Love (Live)
11) Shut Us Down
12) Did You Miss Me
13) Gift of Screws
14) Seeds We Sow
15) The End of Time
16) Go Your Own Way (Live)

What I'd Want
DISC ONE
Same As Above

DISC TWO
1) Dancing Across The USA
2) Time Bomb Town
3) On The Wrong Side
4) Sick of You
5) Brother and Sister
6) She Acts Like You
7) My Little Demon [Demo Remastered]
8) Peacekeeper [Demo Remastered]
9) Gotta Get Away [Demo Remastered]
10) Say Goodbye [Demo Remastered]

Best Of Buck
 

Here is my current imaginary Best Of album track list.
- I limited it to 12 songs.
- I excluded anything originally released as Fleetwood Mac.
- I tried to be representative, but my bias for his 90s tracks (OOTC and the GOS demos) comes through.
- The first half are songs that I think are listenable for the widest audience, and are mostly in major key.
- The second half is more virtuoso and more minor key.
- Sorry for any notable exceptions (e.g. Go Insane the song). Nothing against them! He can put them on the Best Of Volume II.

1 - You Do Or You Don't (Out of the Cradle)
2 - Wait For You (Gift of Screws)
3 - Trouble (Law and Order)
4 - Love Runs Deeper (Gift of Screws)
5 - Down On Rodeo (Under the Skin)
6 - Shut Us Down (Under the Skin)

7 - Wrong (Out of the Cradle)
8 - To Try For The Sun (Under the Skin)
9 - This Is The Time (incl. intro) (Out of the Cradle)
10 - She Acts Like You (This is 40 OST)
11 - Stars Are Crazy (Seeds We Sow)
12 - Play In The Rain (edit) (Go Insane)
* No such 'edit' currently exists; I basically mean an edit that would shorten this song by limiting it more to just the first minute or so and then most of the B side.