Stevie's voice on last 2 Mac tours...

[BigLee770]

There's been some debate recently on the Stevie forum about the quality of Stevie's voice after her performance on Ellen singing Stand Back.

I also recall on this forum previously there being a poll about whether you thought Stevie sounded better singing Beautiful Child on the Say You Will Tour or Storms on the Unleashed Tour...

So what i was wondering, for the people who went to both, do you think Stevie's voice sounded better during the Say You Will tour or on the more recent Unleashed tour?

Personally I only got to see the band at the Unleashed Tour in Dublin as i wasn't old enough when they toured Belfast for Say You Will, so i can't really comment objectively. However at Dublin (I went on the first night) I thought Stevie sounded pretty good...

Just interested to see what other people's thoughts are...

[HejiraNYC]

^^Yes, first night in Dublin was great, second night, not so much. First night at Wembley was phenomenal.

I think Stevie's performances on Unleashed were a mixed bag- definitely not as consistent as SYW. But some songs improved on Unleashed, e.g., "Sara," while others suffered, e.g., "Gypsy." I would have to say that they are pretty much equal, but I will give the edge to SYW for consistency.

[Artemis]

I quitre liked Rhiannon more on the unleashed tour... so I'm gojnna go for that. To me, Storms and BC livr, just sdounfrf... dull. The stuido versions weare the best!

[jcalzaretta]

That performance on Ellen was not good. What I recall from Unleashed and Say You Will was 2 amazing performances - Beautiful Child and Storms.

[Christopher]

My 2 cents, I thought they were about equal.

For SYW, Stevie seemed uninspired singing (& in general) about the new material (that we would find out later she was less than enthusiastic about) But she did "Beautiful Child" justice. I thought she was more stoic on this tour. Remember all the rumblings on the Ledge, that perhaps she was having hip/joint problems.

For Unleashed, Stevie seemed much happier to not have to perform/sell new material and it showed in her demeanor & singing. She did "Storms" justice, but needs to put SS to bed.

So add up the plus's and subtract the negatives and I end up with just about equal. But I gave the nod to Unleashed, Probably because it's fresher on my mind & I remember being in the arena, thinking that she was singing technically better than ever. Her pitch was great, she sings cautiously while still hitting some great notes but her harmony was flawless & spot on. Like I said the only cringe moment for me was when she did Silver Springs, But the general crowd eats up the drama of that song to much to even notice.

[~GoldDustWoman~]

I thought i was the only one who didn't like the Ellen performance I watched it on You Tube (dvred it but haven't watched it), and was like uuhhhh don't like this performance other then the long note at the end.

Never saw any of these tours, but saw a video of Beautiful Child and though the original was better cause i love the high notes she hits it soo beautiful! I like Storms too but i haven't heard a live version.

[Meowi]

Originally Posted by BigLee770

There's been some debate recently on the Stevie forum about the quality of Stevie's voice after her performance on Ellen singing Stand Back.

I also recall on this forum previously there being a poll about whether you thought Stevie sounded better singing Beautiful Child on the Say You Will Tour or Storms on the Unleashed Tour...

So what i was wondering, for the people who went to both, do you think Stevie's voice sounded better during the Say You Will tour or on the more recent Unleashed tour?

Personally I only got to see the band at the Unleashed Tour in Dublin as i wasn't old enough when they toured Belfast for Say You Will, so i can't really comment objectively. However at Dublin (I went on the first night) I thought Stevie sounded pretty good...

Just interested to see what other people's thoughts are...

Good or bad feedback?

[BigLee770]

Mostly bad Meowi.
Quite a lot think she started out off pitch and it continued that way through-out. Most would agree that the best part of it was her sustained note for "why don't you take me home...."
Personally I thought she wasn't awful but by no means was it a "good" Stevie performance...

Here's the link...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyp3iIiI9S8